JSP signing an example of Celtic’s recruitment incompetence

Jahmai Simpson-Pusey Exit Highlights Ongoing Issues in Celtic’s Recruitment Strategy

Jahmai Simpson-Pusey’s short and forgettable spell at Celtic has come to an end, with the young Manchester City centre-back returning to the Etihad after his loan deal was terminated early due to a lack of game time.

The England youth international arrived in Glasgow last summer with a decent reputation and plenty of promise, but his time at the club never truly got going. Across his brief stay, Simpson-Pusey managed just two senior appearances, hardly the platform a developing defender needs to progress.

In truth, his departure comes as little surprise.

A Signing That Never Quite Made Sense

From the outside, Simpson-Pusey’s arrival always felt like a move driven more by opportunity than necessity. Celtic’s defensive needs were well known, yet the loanee never looked like a player the coaching staff were desperate to use.

Despite managerial changes and persistent issues at the back, he remained on the fringes. Neither Brendan Rodgers, Martin O’Neill, nor later Wilfried Nancy — even when options were limited — showed any real inclination to integrate him into the starting XI.

That alone raises questions about how and why the deal was sanctioned in the first place.

Recruitment Without Alignment

Simpson-Pusey’s case fits an increasingly familiar pattern at Celtic. Recent windows have seen several players arrive with little impact, often appearing disconnected from the manager’s plans or the team’s immediate needs.

Names like Shin Yamada, Michel-Ange Balikwisha, and Sebastian Tounekti spring to mind — signings that promised depth or potential but ultimately failed to shift the needle in a struggling squad.

The concern for many supporters is not just that these moves haven’t worked, but that they suggest a recruitment process lacking clear direction. When players are brought in without the full backing or trust of the manager, the outcome is usually predictable.

A Difficult Situation for the Player

It’s also important to acknowledge the human side of the situation. Simpson-Pusey likely arrived in Glasgow expecting meaningful first-team opportunities, the chance to compete for honours, and exposure to European football.

Instead, he found himself watching from the sidelines, unable to build momentum or confidence. For a young defender at a crucial stage of his development, that scenario benefits no one.

Returning to Manchester City, where his progress can be properly assessed and managed, is probably the right move for all involved.

Lessons Still Not Learned?

For Celtic, however, this episode is another reminder of deeper structural issues. Recruitment only works when there is alignment between the boardroom, the football department, and the manager. Without that, signings risk becoming expensive placeholders rather than solutions.

Simpson-Pusey’s exit may not define the season on its own, but it adds to a growing list of questions about how decisions are being made behind the scenes — and whether the club is truly learning from past mistakes.

Until that changes, similar stories are likely to keep repeating.